The Plantagenets: Henry II (1154-1189)

Even from a young age Henry was a born ruler. He was a firebrand speaker, full of energy and vitality. At the age of sixteen, Henry became Duke of Normandy, and upon the death of his father he became the Count of Anjou, Turlaine, and Maine in the French regions. His father was Geoffrey V Count of Anjou the second husband of Matilda or “Maud.” Geoffrey was sometimes called “Geoffrey Plantagenet” because he was often found outside riding with the sprig of broom plant (or planta genesta) in his hat. Thus, the moniker “plantagenet” became synonymous with the family’s ruling bloodline which governed England for some 300 years. Henry’s immediate ancestors became known as the Angevins (or “people from Anjou”). He and his mother Matilda had attacked Stephen’s disputed rule in England while Henry bore the emblem of his house, the sprig of yellow broom plant, the Planta Genesta and so a great dynasty called the Plantagenets became the warrior kings and queens of England.

Henry beat back invading forces in Normandy before invading England, and his arrival on the isle was a triumphant affair. However, the nobles favored neither Stephen nor Henry. They were inclined toward divided rulership by stalemate. A weak king meant an elevated gentry. However, the promise of peace and security plus vast new lands in France was alluring to the barons. An agreement was eventually reached in 1153. Stephen would become king and he would name Henry as his heir to the throne (both Stephen’s wife and his son Eustace had already died). Within one year, Stephen would also be dead and Henry acceded the throne on December 19, 1154 in an ornate coronation ceremony at Westminster Abbey. Henry was only 21 years old when he was crowned King of England. Winston Churchill praises the reign of Henry II as one of the most “pregnant and decisive reigns in English history” (83). It brought much-needed stability to the crown after the tumultuous era known as “The Anarchy.”

A 12th century portrayal of Henry and his mother Matilda

Broadly speaking, Henry II was an enviable man, a lover of the chase and riding (despite the church’s objections), red-haired and freckled, yet he was also moody and immersed himself in the public’s business day and night amidst frequent travel and long hours of work. Per Peter Akroyd, Henry was a man always in motion. He was fidgety and restless even in church.

Henry Plantagenet quickly established a firmly Christian, Latinized kingship over the disparate English lands: England, Ireland, and Scotland. He reaffirmed the government of Henry I, and he also laid claim to a vast empire. At the age of sixteen he inherited Normandy as the great-grandson of William The Conqueror. After his father’s death he inherited Anjou (i.e. The ‘Angevin Empire’ from his mother Matilda’s second cousin Geoffrey of Anjou), and when he married Eleanor of Aquitaine in 1152 he also gained the territory of southwestern France (Aquitaine). Eleanor was 9 years his senior. She was one of the most powerful monarchs in Western Europe (she once led the forces of Christendom in the Second Crusade). She had previously been Queen of France having been married to Louis VII of France. It was a loveless and childless marriage so it was annulled and within weeks Eleanor married the vivacious young king Henry II, who now controlled more regions of France than the French King! Indeed, Henry spent much of his reign in France, rather than in England. He preferred to speak either solely in French or Latin.

Henry’s greatest contribution to the kingship of England was his reformation of the laws and institutions, including the establishment of Common Law as well as the precedent of trial by jury in the royal courts. During this era Ranulph de Glanville penned his famous Treatise on the Laws and Customs of England, as royal or national law preceded regional or local magistrates. As Winston Churchill notes, “England has had greater soldier-kings and subtler diplomats than Henry II, but no man has left a deeper mark upon our laws and institutions. The names of his battles have vanished with their dust, but his fame will live with the English Constitution and the English Common Law” (89) -the latter is in reference to Glanville’s Treatise on the Laws and Customs of England.

The Murder of Thomas Becket, Archbishop of Canterbury
As part of his impressive legal reforms, Henry strongly attempted to force the Church to bend the knee and submit to the laws of the English nation, though ultimately he failed in this endeavor and the task was bitterly left to Henry VIII many centuries later. Henry II’s goal was to unify the administration and laws of the nation. He was successful in subordinating the baron’s and their ‘baronial court system’ to the authority of the royal courts, but he was less successful with the church. In contrast to the barons, the Church had its own set of rules, laws, customs, land-holdings, and it was accountable not to the King of England but rather to the Pope in Rome. A ruling schism between church and state had emerged in England.

The most famous tale of Henry II was his rocky relationship with a former friend and noted clergyman, the Archbishop of Canterbury Thomas Becket. In the medieval world the Church was a massive landholder that was respected even by the robber barons, but it was in constant tension with the state -it was the “root question of the European world” (Churchill, 84). In Thomas Becket, Henry thought he had found a staunch ally. Becket had loyally served in Henry’s court and toward the end of establishing a new state, but, for reasons befuddling to contemporary historians, shortly after Becket was appointed Archbishop in 1162 he changed his tune and immediately began championing the power of the church against the kingship of Henry. In the 11th century Pope Gregory rose to power and he also began enforcing a rule of support for the church over and against the state. Archbishop Becket followed in Pope Gregory’s footsteps as the church attempted to reassert dominance.

The conflict between King and Archbishop deteriorated and appeals to the papacy were made on both sides. The tension rapidly came to a head when Henry forced Becket to publicly submit to his god-ordained authority in a series of 16 articles entitled the Constitutions of Clarendon which Becket reluctantly accepted, but then immediately renounced soon after the fact, claiming he was coerced and under duress in the proceedings. Following his vacillation, Becket retreated to the continent to live in French exile while the turmoil between Church and State spread to other countries like Italy and Germany. In response, Henry II appointed his young son (the future Henry III) to become the future king, but the elder Henry deliberately excluded his Archbishop Becket from the ceremony, spawning much resentment. Becket turned his eye southward toward Canterbury where he retreated and built up his defenses. The whole surrounding region of Kent became a kind of hub for rebellion against the king and his irreligious stance. Rumors circulated that Becket was excommunicating clergy who sided with King Henry II. Upon hearing the news in France, during a characteristic momentary outburst, Henry loudly declared: “What a pack of fools and cowards I have nourished in my house, that not one of them will avenge me of this turbulent priest!” Four knights of the realm overheard the King’s words and promptly headed for the coast. They crossed the Channel and arrived in Canterbury on December 29, 1179. There, they found the Archbishop inside the cathedral and cut him down near the altar in a single bloody and capricious act of vengeance.

A 12th century depiction of the murder of Thomas Becket

“…a third knight inflicted a terrible wound as he pay prostrate, at which blow the sword struck the stone paving, and the crown of the head, which was large was separated from the rest, so that the blood, whitened by the brains, and the brains, reddened with the blood, stained the floor of the cathedral with the white of the lily and the red of the rose, the colours of the Virgin Mother of the Church…” (the eyewitness testimony of Edward Grim, who was injured while attempting to shield the Archbishop).

Upon learning of the brutal assassination all of England including the King was horrified. Sacred law had been violated, the tension between church and state had imploded, and Becket suddenly became a martyr while rumors circulated about the miraculous power of his robes and icons. His ghost loomed large over the remainder of Henry’s reign.

The later years of the first Plantagenet King were plagued by troubles within his family particularly with regard to the succession of the kingdom. Henry intended that England, Normandy, Maine, and Anjou should be given to his eldest son also named Henry (“The Young King”). His next son Richard was to be granted northern Aquitaine, Geoffrey was married to the heiress of Brittany, and the youngest son John was curiously not granted any lands despite being his father’s favorite son -hence his nickname John “Lackland.”

In 1173 King Henry changed his tune. He granted John several castles in Anjou which immediately caused an uproar among his three elder sons. When Queen Eleanor sided with the elder sons, some of the resentful barons across the kingdom joined sides and a full-scale revolt broke out, later called the “Great Rebellion.” It was quickly ended with the capture of the Scottish King in July 1174 and Queen Eleanor was imprisoned by King Henry for the next 15 years. They were estranged for their remaining years, but Eleanor lived long into the reign of her children: Richard and John.

More internal squabbles continued in 1182-1183 but the crisis ended when Henry “The Younger” died of dysentery in the course of a campaign against his father thus making Richard the presumptive heir. However, King Henry divided his kingdom again which caused further strife. Richard allied himself with John and the King of France against his father. King Henry’s hands were tied. He was forced to name Richard as his heir and pay homage to the French king for his lands in France. It has been called a humiliating end to a brilliant tenure as king -brought to his knees by a rebellious son. Henry Plantagenet died on July 6, 1189. His last words were reportedly “Shame… shame on a conquered king.”

Henry and Eleanor were buried at Fontevraud Abbey near Chinon, France.

For this reading I used Winston Churchill’s essential History of English Speaking Peoples, David Starkey’s Crown and Country, Peter Ackroyd’s FoundationThe History of England From Its Earliest Beginnings To The Tudors, and The Anglo-Saxon Chronicle.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s