Broken Blossoms (1919) Review


Broken Blossoms (1919) Director: D. W. Griffith (David Wark Griffith)



Full of innocence and simplicity, Broken Blossoms is a charming picture. It is meticulously crafted with striking cinematography. Broken Blossoms is by far my favorite of D.W. Griffith’s films, though it is unfortunately often overlooked in favor of his much larger and more controversial films. There is surely room to criticize Broken Blossoms for its use of racial stereotypes in helping to fan the flames of the early 20th century “yellow peril,” but I think there are still some redeeming qualities worth exploring.

Entitled Broken Blossoms: The Yellow Man and The Girl, the film is an impassioned tragedy and a masterpiece of the silent era. It stands in contrast to Griffith’s other massive epics, such as The Birth of a Nation (1915) or Intolerance (1916). Broken Blossoms is a gentler and more sensitive picture, even sentimental and melancholic. The story was adopted from Thomas Burke’s short story entitled “The Chink and the Child” taken from his book, Limehouse Nights. The movie was filmed almost entirely on two small indoor sets in order to capture the delicate and intimate nature of the film, as instructed by Henrick Sartov, Griffith’s cinematographer. In total, Broken Blossoms was shot in less than three weeks, but despite its quick filming schedule, the film was a box office success for United Artists.

The film stars Lillian Gish (as Lucy, or the Girl), Richard Barthelmess (The Yellow Man) who controversially played the character in “yellow face,” and Donald Crisp (Battling Burrows) who also played General Ulysses S. Grant in The Birth of a Nation and also previously worked as an assistant to D.W. Griffith for many years before becoming a film director on his own.

The film opens with the tinted blue image of a ship arriving in a harbor and the title reads:

“It is a tale of temple bells, sounding at sunset before the image of Buddha; it is a tale of love and lovers; it is a tale of tears.

We may believe there are no Battling Burrows, striking the helpless with brutal whip – but do we not ourselves use the whip of unkind words and deeds? So, perhaps, Battling may even carry a message of warning.”

It begins in a port town in China where a young Chinese man (The Yellow Man) is contemplating a journey while receiving advice from a Buddhist priest. He witnesses several Western sailors fighting outside and decides he will go to England to be a Buddhist missionary, to “take a glorious message of peace to the barbarous Anglo-Saxons, sons of turmoil and strife.” There are two scenes of a Buddhist monk ringing a bell –we can almost hear the bell despite the film’s silence. He boards a ship for the Limehouse district of London, a foggy slum of the city. He lives there for years working at the Cheng Huan shop selling Chinese trinkets. He spends his years smoking opium at the “scarlet house of sin” after becoming disillusioned with his idealistic cause. The next title reads: “In this scarlet house of sin, does he ever hear the temple bells? There are no more scenes of the bell ringing.

We meet the illegitimate daughter of Battling Burrows, Lucy, who is badly beaten after Battling Burrows’s manager grows angry at him for drinking. She receives advice from a group of some ‘women of the street’ who tell her not to get married but to sell her body instead. After her father beats her, she pitifully moves her fingers over her mouth to force a smile, as per his requests.


Later, the Yellow Man meets two men, both Anglican clergymen, and one is preparing to travel to China to “Convert the heathen.” They hand the Yellow Man a book entitled “Hell.” Lucy goes out shopping and the Yellow Man spots her and notes her beauty. She is also followed by a man called “Evil Eye”. She tries to purchase a single flower in exchange for tin foil from a shop keeper, but she is denied. She grows concerned as she is cornered by Evil Eye, but the Yellow Man rescues her.

Lucy returns home but her angry father beats her again until she passes out. When she awakens, she wanders down to the dock and collapses onto the floor of the Yellow Man’s shop. He carries her upstairs and lavishly takes care of her and allows her to sleep (this extended scene lasts for the bulk of the film). Meanwhile, Burrows is fighting in the ring. One of his associates at the ring visits the Yellow Man’s shop and the Yellow Man must leave to fill his request, but the associate overhears something break upstairs, a jar of flowers dropped by Lucy. So he quietly goes upstairs as the Spying One, and spots her. Laughing, he leaves to inform Battling Burrows. Burrows comes to the shop and ruins the whole room in a fury while the Yellow Man is away picking up flowers for Lucy.

Battling Burrows and Lucy return home and he begins to beat her but she escapes into the closet for the famously violent scene, which even stunned Griffith during the filming. The Yellow Man races to her house but he is too late as Burrows has axed his way into the closet and beats her to death. The Yellow Man finds Lucy lying dead on the bed and Burrows emerges as they stare each other down until Burrows tries to grab his axe but The Yellow Man shoots him several times and takes the body of Lucy back to a room in his shop. In Burk’s short story, Cheng Huan (The Yellow Man) actually puts a poisonous snake in Burrows bed to kill him.

The film closes as the Yellow Man lights a candle and says a Buddhist prayer before a small alter. He rings a small bell once, bidding farewell to his White Blossom, and then he dramatically stabs himself beside the dead body of Lucy just before the police show up to arrest him. Two scenes of the Buddhist bell ringing and the ship entering the harbor are shown, just as in the beginning of the film.

Lillian Gish later claimed theatres that premiered the film in New York were all decorated with ornate draperies, flowers, moon lanterns, and beautiful Chinese artwork. However, on a darker note, the scenes of child abuse in the film naturally disgusted many critics, including Griffith during the filming, and it ultimately drew many away from the film. Broken Blossoms was released during a period of great antagonism toward Chinese immigrants, known as the “Yellow Peril” and it has since been met with much criticism for its portrayal of Asians. Similar prejudicial themes can be found in another early classic, Cecil B. DeMille’s The Cheat (1915).

1 thought on “Broken Blossoms (1919) Review

  1. Pingback: Orphans of the Storm | Great Books Guy

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s